Why Laptops

4/21/05

RE: The Cobb County Laptop issue


The question I have is why do all discussions of computer for students start and end with laptops? Rather than issue laptops to the students why not look at computerizing the desks in the classroom? First of all, the desktops would be significantly cheaper. They would not be subject to being left at home. They would not be subject to being pitched around when a pickup basketball game starts. They offer all of the perceived advantages that the laptops offer but not the down side. It is a lot harder to lose a desktop machine.

The desktop machines would be a lot cheaper to replace as they age--only the CPU portion would need replacement routinely. The monitor and other components would not need routine replacement. They would only need changing in the event of failure.

The desktops are easier to maintain and will not have failing batteries causing disruption in class. It would allow the same computer based education that the laptops do but be easier and cheaper to use.

Most of the students in this county have access to computers and internet at home. Those that do not may need to have the capability to "check one out" from the school for the year or for shorter periods of time. A small pool at each school should be able to handle that.

I know that this letter will not change the minds of any of the brain-locked 5 but I had not seen this proposal anywhere. It would be a possible compromise to the acrimony that currently exists.
Harry Flair